Al Tamur Traders

Monday, September 26, 2011

JAWABAAT-E-BARELWIYAT(PART 2)

BISMILLAHHIRRAHMANIRRAHEEM



JAWABAAT-E-BARELWIYAT



Q 24 Nabi alehissala m Ki Wiladat Par Khushi Manane Ko Qur'an Se Sabit Karen?


BARELWI--"Aap Keh Dijye ALLAH Ke Fazal Aur REHMAT Ke Husool Par Khushi Manao"

(Younus V#58)

"Aur Hum Ne Aap Ko Tamam Jahano Ke Lye REHMAT Bana Kar Bheja"

(Anbyaa V107)

Donu Aayat Ko Samjen! Faisla Aap Par He!


AHLE HADITH-- Samjhen nahi samjhaao !! Jashn e milaad kahan se saabit ho raha hai..... Kya ye ayat sahaba kiram ra ko samjh na aayi ki ye jashn e meelad ke talluq se hain??

Kya sahaba kiram aap(sws) se bugz rakhte they ??(nauzubillah)



Q 25Hidayet Kon Deta He?


BARELWI--Hamara Emaan He K ALLAH Ki Marzi k Khilaf Nabi Hidayat Nhe Karte Magar ALLAH Ki Ataa Se Nabi Hidayet Karte Hen

"Aur Tum Aye Mehbub Hidayat Karte Ho Seedhe Raaste Ki"

(AlShura V#52)

Rab Ne Huzoor Ko HAADI Bana Kar Bheja Aur HAADI Aapka Sifaati Name Bhi He


AHLE HADITH-- Beshak har nabi ne seedhe raaste ki taraf bulaya...

Aur hidayat dena allah ka kaam hai aur nabi(as) sirf daraane waale hain

Shayad barelwi hazraat ne abu taalib ka kissa nahi suna hai jisme aap(sws) ne unse qalmah padhne ke liye kaha lekin unko qalmah padhna naseeb na huwa aur allah ne ye ayat utari..

" nabi aur imaanwaalon ke liye sahi nahi ki mushrikon ke liye maghfirat ki dua karen, bhale hi we rishtedaar ho, jabki un par saaf ho chuka hai ki we log jahannami hai

(quran 9/11)

aur yah ayat bhi utri

" aap jise pasand karen, hidayat nahi de sakte"

(surah 28/ayat 56)





Q.26 Shirk ki Tareef Karen?


BARELWI-- Ek Se Zyada Khuda Man'na Yani ALLAH Ki Zaat, Sifat Ya Af'aal Me Kisi Ko Wesa Hi Samaj Kar Sharik Karna. Ya Kisi Ghairullah Ko Mustahiq e Ibadat W aristish Jan'na Ahlesunnat Ko Khumakhwa Mushrik Kehne Wale Is Tarif Ki Roshni Me Mushrik Saabit Karen!


AHLE HADITH-- ham wajeh karte hain shirk kya hai




" abu saeed khudri ra se riwayat hai ki aap(sws) ne farmaya:" beshak hi tum pahli ummaton ki pairwi me aise barabar ho jaaoge jaise teer teer se, yahantak ki agar we goh ke bil me ghusenge to tum bhi ghusoge, sahaba ne arz kiya ki yahud wa Nasaara ki pairwi ham karenge? Farmaya to phir kaun?

(bukhari,muslim)



Hazrat Ayesha se riwayat hai ke Ume Salm (RA) neNabi (S A A W) se aik girje ka zikar kiya jo unhun ne Mulik e Habsha m daikha tha or us m jo Tasaaweer thin unke mutaliq byaan kiya. Nabi S A A W ne irshad frmaya un logun mye riwaj tha ke jab koi naik shakhs fot ho jata to wo uski qabar ke qareeb masjid bana liya karte or masjid m us marne wale ki tasaweer kunda kar diya karte. Wo log jo aisa karte the Allah ke nazdeek badtareen khalaiq the isliye ke unhun ne do

(2)fitne yakjaa kar diye

No (1)Qabar Parsti ka fitna

No(2)tasweer saazi ka fitna.

(sahih bukhari)


JO SIFAAT ALLAH KI HAIN USE BARELWI HAZRAAT NE APNE PEERO KO DE RAKHA HAI.. KYA YE KHULA SHIRK NAHI ??



(1) GAUS-E-AAZAM (SabseBada Faryaad Sunne Wala )

"Kaun hai jo beqarar ki dua sunta hai jab ke wo usse pukare aur kaun uski taklif ko door karta hai, aur kaun hai jo tumhe zameen ka khalifa banata hai ! Kya Allah ke sath aur koi Mabood hai ?


(Surah- Tul-Namal, Aayat-no--62)


(2) MUSKIL-KUSHA (Tamaam Mushkilen halkarne wala)

Agar tumhe Allah kisi mushkil me daal de to iske siwa isko koi door karne wala nahi aur agar wo tumhe kisi khaer(bhalai) se nawazna chahe to wo har chiz par qadir hai.


(Aanaam 17 )


(3)DAATA (Sab Kuch DeneWala)

Besak Allah bada denewala hai.

(Al-Quraan)

Jise chhata hai betiyan deta hai, jise chhata hai bete deta hai, jise chhata hai bete aur betiyan mila jhula kar deta hai, aur jise chhata hai banjh rakh deta hai, wo to janne wala Qudrat wala hai"

(ash Shura,49,50)





Q.27 Bid'at ka Mafhum Bataen?


BARELWI--Har Wo Kaam Jiski Koi Asal Bilwasta Ya Bilawasta Na Quran Me Ho Na Sunnate Rasul Me Ho, Aur Ise Zaruryat e Deen {Jiska Inkar Kufr He} Me Shumar Karte Huey Shamil e Deen Kar Dya Jaye Mutlaqan Har Naye Kaam Ko Az Roo e Shara Is Lye Bid'at Kehna K Wo Naya He To Is Se Shariat Ki Taalimat Me Kam o Besh 80 % Kaam Najaaiz Ho Jaayenge Agar Kisi Ko Ikhtilaf He To Challenge He K Bid'at Ki Koi Tareef


AHLE HADITH-- To phir aap lo fajr ki farz namaz me 2 ki jagah 10 rakat padha karona..... BIDATE HASANA HAI


Abhi aapko bidat ki tareef hi nahi malum...

Bidat karne se pahle ye to malum kar liya karo ki ye bidat quran wa hadith se saabit bhi hai ya nahi..... Hamare liye hujjat quran wa hadith hai fir ijma...

Jaisa ki eid ul miladun nabi manane par ijmaa nahi hai 4 imam iske mukhaalif hain..... Phir aap kyon manate hain??

Ham batate hain aapko bidat ki tareef




" deen me har nai baat bidat hai"

(nisai)


" jisne deen me koi aisa kaam kiya jiski buniyaad shariat me nahi wah mardood hai"

(bukhari wa muslim)

" tabaahi hai, tabaahi hai, unke liye jinhone mere baad deen ko badal daala"

(bukhari, muslim)

" bidati ki himayat karne waale par allah taala ki laanat hai"

(muslim)


Q 28 Kya Sarkar alehissala m ALLAH Ka Rizq Taqseem Karte Hen?



BARELWI--AAQA (alehissalam): Be Shak ALLAH Dene Wala He Aur Me TAQSEEM Karta Hun

(Bukhari J#1 P#439) (Muslim J#1 P#333)

Emaan Mila Inke Sadqey, Qur'an Mila Inke Sadqey, Rehman Mila Inka Sadqey Wo Kya Jo Hum Ne Paya Nhe.


AHLE HADITH-- Ye hadith out of context hai... Aapne rizq ke mutalliq sawaal kiya jabki hadith me rizq ka koi zikr nahi....

Beshak yah hadith jo aapne pesh ki hai yah rizq ke talluq se nahi ya phir isa hawala ghalat pesh kiya gaya hai..


Is hadith se ye bhi malum huwa ki allah aap(sws) par wahiy karta hai aur aap(sws) logon tak iska ilm pahunchaate hain.....

Yahan barelwi hazraat ne is hadith ka ghalat matlab nikaala. Warna ye poori hadith quote karte..

Allah inhe hidayat de..





Q.29 YA RASOOLALLA H (Aye ALLAH K Rasool) Pukarna Kese Jaaiz He?


BARELWI--NAMAZ Me ATTAHEYAAT Parhte Hen Jis Me He "ASSALAMU ALAIKA AYYUHAN NABIYU" (Aye NABI Aap Pr Salamti Ho)

'YA' Harf e Nida Kisi Ko Pukarne K Lye Aata He Aur 'AIYUHAN' Me 'A' Hrfe Nida He, Jab NAMAZ Me Ye Parhna Wajib He To NAMAZ K Baahir Kese Jaaiz Nhe?

Aur Buhat Si Ahadis Hen Jin Me Sarkar alehissalam Ke Parda Farmane Ke Baad Sahaba Ne Ye Seega Sarkar Ke Lye Arz Kya


AHLE HADITH-- Accha sawal hai is jawab main bukhari ki hadith se dene ki koshish karunga


" hz abdullah bin masood ra bayan karte hai ki jab tak aap(sws) hamare beech maujood rahe ham " assalaamu alaika ayyuhan nabiyyu" kahte rahe, jab aap rukhsat ho gaye to hamne khitaab ka qalimah chhodkar ghayab ka qalimah padhna shuru kar diya, yami phir ham " assalaau alan nabiyyu " padhte they"


(bukhari 6265)




Pahle jumle ka maana hai:-" aiy nabi aap par salaamati ho" dusre ka maana hai:-" nabi akram(sws) par salamati ho" phir bhi baad me dobara " assalamu alaika ayyun nabiyyu pada jaane laga, isse malum huwa ki sahaba kiram ra nabi akram(sws) ko alimul ghaib, hajir o najir nahi samjhte they warna ek din ke liye bhi "alaika ayyunhan nabiyyu " ki jagah " alan nabiyyu" nahi padhte





Q.30 Agar Deen Me Koi Naya Acha Kaam Ho Jo Shariat Se Na Takraye To Uske Lye Kya Fazeelat He, Misaal Bhi Den?


BARELWI--Sarkar sallallahu alehi wasallam : Mere Baad Koi Aisa Amal Jaari Kare Jo Deen Ki Asal Se Mutazad Na Ho Qayamat Tak Us Pe Amal Karne Walon Ka Bi Sawab Paye Ga

(MUSLIM)

E.g: QURAN ki Mojuda Tartib

Kitabi Surat

Earab o Tarajim Ahadees,

Us ki Asnaad o Usool Tiraweeh

Jumey Ki Azaan e Saani Jalsey,

Masajid Ki Mojuda Surat..


AHLE HADITH-- Bidat ki tareef uper guzar chuki hai.....

Agar deen me naya kaam bidat e hasana hai to barelwiyon ko chahiye ki ramzaan ke roze ek mahine ke bajaaye 2 mahine rakha karen....

Quran ki tarteeb, jumah ki do azaane, hurf, namaz e taraweeh wa jamaat... Ye sab kaam khulefa ras hidoon ke haath huwa isliye ye bidat nahi hai... Aur is par ijma hai..

11wi, 12wi,13wi, 40wa, khatam shareef etc etc se sab bidat e kabeera hain kyonki ye sunnat ke khilaf hain aur is par ijma nahi hai





Q.31 Kya Sarkar Ko Har Baat (Gaib) Ka Elm He?


BARELWI--Hazrat Umer Ne Kaha: Sarkar alehissala m Hamare Darmiyan Khare Hue, Aur AAP Ne IBTEDA e DUNIYA Se Le Kar JANNATIYON Aur DOZAKHIYON Tak Ki Khabar Di Use Jis Ne Yaad Rakha, So Yaad Rakha Aur Jo Bhool Gaya So Bhool Gaya


(Bukhari J1 P#453)


AHLE HADITH-- ilm e ghaib ke talluk se uper guzar chuka hai..


Ye waqeya allah ka mojeza tha jo usne apne habeeb muhammad (sws) ko dikhaaya...





Q.32 Kya ALLAH K Naik BANDEY Kisi K Dilon Ka Haal Jaante Hen?


BARELWI--Hadees: MOMIN Ki Firaasat Se Daro, Be Shak Wo ALLAH Ke NOOR Se Dekhta He

(Tirmizi J2 P 614)

Ab Agar Koi Walyo Ki Basaarat Ya Elm Par Aetraaz Karey To Goya Us Ne Noor e Elahi Ko Apne Gandey Aetraaz Ka Nishana Banaya

AHLE HADITH-- Miyan quran ki ayat pesh kar rahe ho ya hadith, agar hadith to ye jhoot hai poori hadith bayan karen raawi ke saath... Jisse is hadith ki asliyat saamne aaye.


Allah hi dilon ke haal jaanta hai, lekin aap ise ambiya aur peer mureedon me bhi tasleem karne lag gaye..... Ye to tawheed par khuli chhot hui. Aur waise bhi is hadith me waliyon ke ilm e ghaib ka saboot nahi mil raha hai


surah maida ki ayat jo uper guzar chuki hai use padhen 116-118



Q.33 Kya ALLAH K Wali Door Se Bi Sun Sakte Aur Dekh Sakte Hen?


BARELWI--HADEES:

ALLAH Apne Nek Bando Ke Mutaliq Farmata He "Me Uske Kaan Hojata Hun Jis Se Wo Sunta He, Uski Ankhen Hojata Hun Jis Se Wo Dekhta He"

(Bukhari J#2P#963)

Yaani Jub ALLAH Ka Noor Unke Kaan, Unki Aankh Hojata He To Wo Door o Nazdeek Ki Pukar Sun Lete Hen, Door Se Hi Mulahiza Karte Hen Aur Mushkil Ko Asaan Karne Per Qaadir Hojate Hen (Tafseer Kabir J#7 P#436)


AHLE HADITH-- Allah taala ne farmaya ! Kahan farmaya quran me ya imam bukhari rh ke paas wahiy naazil hui...

Allah taala ne farmaya hai to quran se daleel do.... Aur ye hadith out of context hai




"AUR USSE BADKAR ZAALIM KAUN HOGA JO ALLAH KE ELAWA KISI AUR KO PUKAARE JO QIYAMAT TAK BHI USKI BAAT NA SUNE BALKI UNKO PUKAARNE KI KHABAR TAK NA HO"

(AHKAAF 5)





Q.34 Ahle Sunnat Aur Ahle Hadees Ka Faraq Bataye?


BARELWI--

Sunnat ki Tareef: Huzoor Ne Hamare Amal k Lye Jis Rah Ko Mutayyen Farmaya Us Rah Ko SUNNAT Kehte Hen

Hadees ki Tareef: Huzoor K Har Qoal Feal Aur Haal Ko HADEES Kehte Hen

@USOOL@ Ek Momin Aamil BisSunnat To Ho Sakta He Aamil Bil Hadees Nahi Ho Sakta Kyu Ke Sunnat Ka Mafhum Hi Ye He K Iske Mutabiq Amal Kya Jaye Jab K Hadees Ka Mafhum Sunnat Se Aam He


AHLE HADITH-- Abhi aapko hadith aur sunnat me farq hi nahi malum

aap(sws) ne 12 shaadiyan ki ye sunnat hai lekin huqm 4 ka diya ye hadith hai

faisla aap karen aap sunnat par amal karenge ya hadith par


sahih bukhri me hai aap(sws) ne khade hokar pesaab kiya.. Sunnat hai lekin huqm baithkar karne ka diya ye hadith hai.

AAP KIS PAR AMAL KARNA PASAND KARENGE SUNNAT YA HADITH

hadith ka mafhoom qur'an se bhi wajeh kar deta hun.. Shayad aapko na malum ho..



Fabiayyi hadeesin badahu yuminoon


"ab iske baad wah kaun si baat par imaan laayenge"


(mursalat 50)


yani hadith par imaan le aao barelwi bhaiyyon!




AHLE BIDAT KI PAHECHAAN:


"ye baat bhi smajh rakho k ahle bid'at ki kuch nishaaniya hai jin se wo pahechane jaate hain

Ahle bid'at AHLE HADEES ki gheebat karta hai.

aur ZANDEEQ ki pahechaan hai k woh AHLE HADEES ko HASHOWIYA kaheta hai.AUR QADIRIYA, AHLEHADEES ko MAJBRAH kaheta hai. aur JAHEMIYA ki alamat hai k wo AHLESUNNAT ​ kanaam MUSHABBAH rakhtehain aur RAAFIZI,AHLE HADEES ko NAASBIYAH ke naam se namzad karte hain.Aur ye sab log ye sab kuch is waaste karte hain ke inko AHLE SUNNAT SE TA'SSUB AUR DUSHMANI HAI aur AHLE SUNNAT ka naam sirf ek hi hai YANI AHLEHADEES iske siwa koi naam inka nahi.

Aur bid'ati jo AHLE SUNNAT k laqab rakhte hain. wo inke naam se bilkul nahi milte.

jaisa ke Ahle Makka ne Paighambar ​ saw. ke naam SAAHIR, SHAAYAR,DEEWANA, AASEEB RASEEDA aur KAAHIN rakhte the haalanki inko rasul saw maqbool saw ke namo aur aapki sifato se koi talluk hinahi.


(ghuniyatu​l Talibeen,Page No. 111 , tarjumaAllama Zaheeruddi ​nBadayuni






Q 35.Sunnat Ke Mafhum Ko Mazeed Waazeh Karen?


BARELWI--Sunnat Ki Tareef Me 2 Baaten Qabil e Gour Hen

1.TAYYUN E AMAL IsKi Qaid Se Wo Amal Kharij Hogaye Jinhe Baad K Ehkaam Ya Aamal Se Mansookh Kar Dya Gaya Jese Rafa Yadain Qunute Nazla Aamin Bil Jehar etc

2.HAMARE AMAL K LYE IsKi Qaid Se Wo Aamal Kharij Hogaye Jo Huzur Ki Khususiyaa t Aur Hamare Lye Jaaiz Nhe Jese Tahajjud Ki Farziyat Soame Wisal 9 Azwaj Ka 1 Waqt Nikah Me etc


AHLE HADITH-- Rafulyadain, amin bil jahar, tark ki koi ahadith maujood nahi...

Rafulyadain aur ameen bil jahar ke masle me 4 mese 3 aimma iske karne ke qayel hain....

Isliye tark saabit hi nahi balki muqallideen ne ise tark karwane ke koshish zaroor kari lekin kamyab na ho saken(alhamdulillah)

isi tarah kunut e nazila bhi mansookh nahi hua

"hz umar bin khattab fajr ki namaz me (ruku ke baad) kunut karte aur yah dua padhte"


(baihaqi 2/210-211)

puri dua ke liye hadith dekhen

agar aap ke nazdeek qunut e nazila mansookh hai to daleel den ki kab mansookh hua





Q.36 Ab Hadees Ke Mafhum Ko Bhi Mazeed Waazeh Karen?


A.Hadees Ka Mafhum Sunnat Se Aam He

1.Huzoor Ne Mazi Haal O Mustaqbil Ki Jo Khabren Deen Wo B Hadees

2.Pichli Ummaton K Aamaal B Hadees K Jin Me Baaz Pe Amal Najaiz

3.Wo Aamal B Hadees Jo Ibtidae Islam Me Mubaah Aur Baad Me Mansukh Maslan Sharaab Noshi

4.Huzoor Ki Khususiyaa t Bhi Hadees Me Mazkoor Jis Pe Hamen Amal Mashru Nhe


AHLE HADITH-- Alhamdulillah aapne tasleem to kiya ki qur'an bhi hadith hai jaisa ki maine pahle bataya

Aap sws ki batayi har baat hadith hai isme sunnat bhi shamil hai kyonki aisa ho nahi sakta ki aap(sws) khud kuch aur amal karen aur ummat ko kuch alag batayen


kuch ahkaam aise hain jo aap sws ke liye khaas hain misaal ke taur par 12 shaadiyon waala masla....

Agar sunni bhai apne apko asli sunni kahte hain to wo isko kyon tasleem nahi karte... Yaha we hadith maante hain

lekin hamare nazdeek sab hadith hain

kyonki quran me hai ki nabi apni taraf se kuch nahi bolta

ham dekhte hain kaun si hadith jayezebul itteba hai




Q.37 HADIS Aur SUNNAT Ke Hawale Apne Kya Wazeh Kya?


BARELWI--Hadees Pr Amal Ka Hukum Nhe Bal K Sirf Puhnchane Ka Hukum He Mujse Sun'nay Waley Gaaib Ko Hadees Puhncha Den

(Bukhari)

Sunnat Pr Amal Ka Hukum He Meri Sunnat Pe Amal Ko Lazim Rakho

(Tirmizi)

Jis Ne Meri Sunnat Se Mu Mora Wo Meri Ummat Se Nhe

(Bukhari)

Sabit Hua Tamaam Ahadees Pe Amal Namumkin Jabk Tamam Sunan Pe Mumkin Pas Musalman Ahle Sunnat Hi Hosakta He....


AHLE HADITH-- jawab de chuka hun pahle...

Sunnah aur hadith ek hi hain...

Kyonki nabi apni taraf se kuch nahi kahta

(quran)

aur sheikh sahab ka farman bhi bata chuka hun ki ahle sunnat ka ek hi naam hai aur wo hai ahle hadith


aapne ka hadith par amal ka huqm nahi balki hadith ko pahunchaane ka huqm hai

to main puchna chahta hun ki quran ki ye ayat jo


" wah iske baad kis baat par emaan layenge"

(mursalat 50)

kya barelwi quran kareem par emaan nahi laaye??

Allah taala farmate hain ki nabi apni marzi se kuch nahi kahta

yani isse sabit huwa hadith bhi wahi e illahi hai..





Q 38.Aqida e Touheed Bataye?


BARELWI--AQIDA E MUTAAL'LIQ Ae Zaat O Sifaate ILAHI ALLAH Ek He Uska Koi Sharik Nahi Na Zaat Me Na Sifaat Me Na Af'aal Me Na Ahkaam Me Na Asmaa Me, Wo Waajibul Wujood He

(Uska Wajud Zaruri He)

Hamesha Se He Aur Hamesha Rahe Ga

{Bahaar e Shariat V#1, P#1}


AHLE HADITH-- Allah ki gawth e azam hai, wahi gharib nawaz, bandanawaz, daata, hai

lekim aap logon ne in sifaaton ko uski makhlook me shamil kar liye

iska khulasa uper ke sawalon me ho chuka hai

is tarah aap tawhee ke inkaari hain






Q 39.ALLAH ke Bandey Jo Madad Krte Hen Uske Mutaliq Hmara Kya Aqida He?


BARELWI--Koi Musalman Kisi Bande Ko ALLAH Ki Misl, Ya Uske Bagair Madadgar Nhe Samajta Aur ALLAH Ki Ataa Se Madad Goya ALLAH Hi Ki Madad He, Kainat Ka Koi Zarra ALLAH Ki Marzi Ke Bagair Madad Nhe Kar Sakta, HAAN Wo Apne Mehbubon Ke Wasila Qubool Krta He Aur Aisa Karne Me Wo Majbur Nhe Balke Jab Wo Kisi Ko Mehboob Banaye To Apni Sifat Ka Inko Mazhar Bana Deta He

(Bukhari)


AHLE HADITH-- yahan barelwi hazrat waseela ke baare sawaal kiya hai main 2 baatein wajeh kar dena chaahta hoo

1- quran kareem se sirf do tarah ka waseela saabit hai (1) iman (2) nek amal

2- jo faut ho gaye unka waseela quran hadith se saabit nahi...

3- zindon se dua karwana hadith se saabit hai jaisa ki dua e isteghaaza e zariya baarish ke liya allah se dua talab karna...

Misal ke taur par main ye kahun ki" maulwi saheb mere liye dua karna ki main paas Ho jaun".. Aur iske baad faisla allah par chhod diya jaaye

allah taala farmata hai

"yahi tumhara rabb h isi ki hukumat h or jinko tum allah k elawa pukarte ho wah khajoor ki guthli(seeds)ke barabar bhi ikhteyaar nahi rakhte,agar tum unko pukaro to we tumhari sunege bhi nahi aur agar sun bhi len to tumhara khuch bhi na kar saken aur qiyamat ke din we tumhare shirk karne se hi inkaar karenge aur tujhko khuday khabeer ka sa koi na batayega"

(fatir 13 ,14)


"Aap kah dijiye tumne apne khudaai shareekon ke haal par bhi nazar ki hai jinhe tum allah ke siwa pukarte ho zara mujhe bhi batao ki unhone zameen ka Kaun sa ansh(part)banaya hai ya unka aasmaan me kuch saajha hai ya hamne unko kitab di hai ki ye usi daleel par qayam hai?"

(fatir 40)

Aur zyada taqeed karte hue farmaya


" aur jinko tum allah ke elawa pukaate ho wah na to tumhari hi madad kar sakte hain aur na apni madad kar sakte hai"


(Aaraf 197)




#UmairSalafiAlHindi
#IslamicLeaks