KYA IMAM KE PEECHE SURAH FATIHA NAHIN PADHNA CHAHIYE ??
Ubada bin Sammit raz riwayat kartehai ke hum Farz ki Namaz Nabi saw ke peche padhte the , Aap saw ne Quran padha to Aap saw par padhna bhari ho gaya , jab Namaz se farig hue to Farmaya , sayad tum apne Imaam ke peche padha karte ho?
Humne kaha ha Allah ke Rasool saw, Aap ne farmaya
Surah Fatiga ke aalawa or kuch na padha karo , kyon ke us shakhs ki
Namaz nahi hoti jo Surah Fatiha na padhe ,
{ Abu Daood ,
kitab us Salath ,
Hadees no 823 ,
Tirmizi , kitab us Salath ,
Hadees no 311 }
kitab us Salath ,
Hadees no 823 ,
Tirmizi , kitab us Salath ,
Hadees no 311 }
Isse Imaam Khuzema , Ibn Hibban or Bahqi ne Sahih kaha , jab ke Imaam Tirmizi or Daur Kutni ne Hasan kaha hai ,
Hadees Hasan hai :Ese Imam Bukhari r.al ne Apne Kitab khalk afa'al Alba'ad (Safa 102,hissa-526) me v ese Sanad wa Matan se bayan keya hai Aur darekutni (1/320 h-1207) wa bahke (Alsunan:2/165) se ne Sadik bin Khalid Aur Abu daood (824) , Nishai (141/2,safa-921) wa Darkutni (1204 , 1/319) ne Zaid bin waqad ki sanad se bakhelaf Aysa rewayat keya(Wakal Bahkqi fi kitab Iqra (Safa-24,Safa121)''
Ese k Rawi Nafeh bin Mohammad : Darekutni,Hakim Zahbi (Alkasaf :3/197) bahqi, Ibn hazam (Alma'hli 3/241,242) aur Ibn Hibban wagaira k Nazdek Seka hai, es per mazul ki Zarra Mardud hai , dekhe Al-kawakab aldarya(Safa-32,33) haram bin hakim (sika) ne makhul ki Mutabek kar rakhe hai, kitab Al qira lil-Bahqi (sfa-121) ki hasan laz'at rewayat k Akher me ye Alfaz hai ''Us se fatiya khalf al imam k Wajib sabit hota hai
Hadees Hasan hai :Ese Imam Bukhari r.al ne Apne Kitab khalk afa'al Alba'ad (Safa 102,hissa-526) me v ese Sanad wa Matan se bayan keya hai Aur darekutni (1/320 h-1207) wa bahke (Alsunan:2/165) se ne Sadik bin Khalid Aur Abu daood (824) , Nishai (141/2,safa-921) wa Darkutni (1204 , 1/319) ne Zaid bin waqad ki sanad se bakhelaf Aysa rewayat keya(Wakal Bahkqi fi kitab Iqra (Safa-24,Safa121)''
Ese k Rawi Nafeh bin Mohammad : Darekutni,Hakim Zahbi (Alkasaf :3/197) bahqi, Ibn hazam (Alma'hli 3/241,242) aur Ibn Hibban wagaira k Nazdek Seka hai, es per mazul ki Zarra Mardud hai , dekhe Al-kawakab aldarya(Safa-32,33) haram bin hakim (sika) ne makhul ki Mutabek kar rakhe hai, kitab Al qira lil-Bahqi (sfa-121) ki hasan laz'at rewayat k Akher me ye Alfaz hai ''Us se fatiya khalf al imam k Wajib sabit hota hai